Who Regulates Sports Prediction Markets After Murphy
In September 2026, New Jersey, Robinhood, and Crypto.com petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to resolve a circuit split concerning who has the authority to regulate sports event contracts offered via prediction markets. (Aislinn Keely, Law360). Prediction markets are defined as “marketplaces where participants buy and sell contracts tied to the outcome of future events.” (Fidelity). Kalshi and Polymarket favor federal oversight of prediction markets, while a group of states argues the platforms should be regulated as gambling by the states. (Zach Schonfeld, The Hill). To show the effects of the issue, Crypto.com pointed out that it could provide this type of contract in Atlantic City without facing interference from the states but would have to obtain a gaming license in Las Vegas to provide the same there. (Aislinn Keely, Law360). This Article will examine the varying regulatory approaches among states, the competing interests of companies and states in governing prediction market sports contracts, and why the Court’s previous decision on sports betting does not resolve the dispute.
The first issue in this dispute is state-by-state regulation. (Zach Zchonfeld, The Hill). In Murphy v. National Collegiate Athletic Association, 584 U.S. 453 (2018), the Court struck down the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (“PASPA”), which generally barred states from allowing sports gambling. (Karl E. Schneider, Congress.gov); SeeMurphy, 584 U.S. at 486. Following this, states took different approaches. (Kambi). For a business operating in more than one state, this could mean a product that is approved in one state could face restrictions in another. Id. Because of this, the question of whether state or federal supervision should apply is particularly salient.
Prediction market companies claim that their sports-related products should be classified as financial “swaps”. (Zach Zchonfeld, The Hill). In this market, companies offer contracts that let customers speculate on the outcomes of games and events that occur during them. (Aislinn Keely, Law360). The companies claim these contracts should be classified as “swaps,” which are a financial instrument regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”). Id.Within the investment context, “swaps” are defined as “a derivative contract where two parties exchange cash flows or liabilities of financial instruments.” (James Chen, Investopedia). While the Ninth Circuit agreed that federal jurisdiction over swaps could supersede state regulations, it ruled that these sports contracts were more like gambling than swap trading. (Aislinn Keely, Law360). The key question is whether Congress gave the CFTC exclusive authority over swaps on its registered markets and whether the companies’ sports wagers fall within that category. (Zach Zchonfeld, The Hill).
Recent court rulings have muddied the regulatory waters even further. In April 2026, the Third Circuit ruled in Kalshi’s favor, a prediction market company, holding that its sports contracts likely fell within the scope of federal authority. (Jennifer Davenport, State of New Jersey Department of Law & Public Safety); see KalshiEx, LLC v. Flaherty, 172 F.4th220 (3d Cir. 2026). However, in August 2026, the Ninth Circuit reached the opposite conclusion in a ruling against Kalshi; the court upheld a lower court’s decision to lift a preliminary injunction that protected Kalshi from Nevada’s gambling regulators. (Marc Levy, AP News); see KalshiEx, LLC v. Assad, 2026 WL 2543846 (9th Cir. 2026). After the Ninth Circuit’s decision, Robinhood and Crypto.com petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to review the circuit court’s decision; meanwhile, Kalshi petitioned the Ninth Circuit for rehearing en banc. (Aislinn Keely, Law360). This division between the circuit courts has real-world effects for companies that are offering the same product in different states.
Companies seemingly have a practical advantage in supporting federal supervision because one set of rules appears to make it easier to operate across state borders. Id. When filing an amicus brief in the Ninth Circuit in February, the CFTC backed this view and cited benefits such as managing financial risks and providing information on future events. (CFTC). The agency proposed rules in June 2026 that would permit a large number of sports contracts, and Robinhood announced in September of this year an agreement with Crypto.com to extend its prediction market services via OG.com. (Aislinn Keely, Law360); (Nathan Bomey, Axios). The deal makes OG.com’s contracts available to a larger audience since Robinhood has over 28 million customers. Id. Thus, both federal regulators and businesses are moving toward wider access even though the states are still challenging federal oversight.
However, there are other reasons for states to oppose that approach apart from wanting to retain control. Forty-four state attorneys general from both sides of the aisle objected to the CFTC’s authority over sports betting in a letter published over the summer. (Zach Schonfeld, The Hill). New Jersey particularly stressed the need for safeguards concerning underage gambling, compulsive betting, and the use of inside information. (Jennifer Davenport, State of New Jersey Department of Law & Public Safety). A 2024 study found a correlation between legalized sports gambling, lower savings, and more financial difficulties (Karl E. Schneider, Congress.gov). The states’ tax revenues and the interests of casinos and tribal governments contribute to the conflict. (Zach Schonfeld, The Hill). If prediction markets draw customers away from state-regulated sportsbooks, the states would lose taxable business revenue, and already established casinos would face new competition. Id.
Murphy provides a good basis for consideration, but it does not resolve this issue. While Murphy permitted the states to make their own decisions, the Court also acknowledged that Congress has the power to regulate sports gambling directly. (Karl E. Schneider, Congress.gov); see Murphy, 584 U.S. at 486). This raises the question of whether Congress already did so by means of the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act, which gave the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over swaps. (Aislinn Keely, Law360). Crypto.com contended that sports outcomes can have economic consequences by leading to more business in the hometown of the winning team, and therefore those contracts would fall within the definition of a swap. Id. New Jersey maintained that Congress did not use a financial reform law (like the Dodd-Frank Act) to take away the state’s authority over sports betting. (Jennifer Davenport, State of New Jersey Department of Law & Public Safety). The arguments show that the result will depend on the extent to which the Court interprets the definition of a swap; Murphy therefore only provides some background information and gives no definitive answer because the issue centers on what Congress authorized, not on which regulator is ultimately best suited for the job. Id.
The circuit split gives the U.S. Supreme Court grounds to hear the case; however, that does not guarantee that the Court will hear it. (Zach Schonfeld, The Hill). Howard Fischer, a partner at Moses Singer, has suggested that the justices might wait until there have been further developments in the lower courts. Id. If the Court takes the case, opposing sides suggest it would examine whether Congress placed these sports contracts under exclusive federal control. (Aislinn Keely, Law360). The conflicting rulings make the Supreme Court review more likely; however, it's still uncertain when it would occur. (Zach Schonfeld, The Hill). A decision in favor of the companies could facilitate nationwide expansion; meanwhile, a decision in favor of the states would maintain existing local restrictions. In either scenario, it would clarify who sets the rules when sports betting and financial markets intersect.